Back to articles

Can WhatsApp Conversations Be Used as Evidence Before the Omani Courts?

Can WhatsApp Conversations Be Used as Evidence Before the Omani Courts?

WhatsApp conversations, emails, and messages exchanged various digital platforms have become an integral part of daily life for individuals and businesses in the Sultanate of Oman: negotiations, agreements, order confirmations, acknowledgments of receipt, and even admissions of debt. With the increase in disputes, a fundamental question repeatedly arises: will the court accept such messages as evidence?

The precise legal answer is: yes, they may be accepted, but subject to specific controls. The court’s assessment of their evidential value depends on their integrity, attribution to their sender, and the reliability of the method by which they were preserved and presented

First: The Regulatory Framework in Oman – What Constitutes an “Electronic Document”?

The Electronic Transactions Law issued by Royal Decree No. 39/2025 provides a broad definition of an electronic document, encompassing: “a contract, record, entry, message… or any other document… created, stored, sent, or received… by electronic means.”

This definition, in principle, places chat messages within the concept of an electronic document

The Law further provides that an electronic document shall be deemed a written document and shall produce its legal effects once it satisfies the statutory requirements relating to its creation and authentication.

Second: Is Submission of the “Original” Required? How Is the “Original” Understood in Digital Communications?

One of the key strengths of the Electronic Transactions Law is that it addresses the concept of the “original” in the digital environment. Where another law requires submission of the original document, an electronic document shall be considered an original if its content can be displayed clearly and if the technically adopted method allows verification of the integrity of the data and protection against tampering.

From a practical perspective, a screenshot alone may serve as an initial indication; however, it is often insufficient in substantial disputes, particularly where denial or allegations of alteration arise. A digital original is not merely a static image, but rather the ability to technically verify the source and integrity of the content.

Third: The Standard for Accepting Electronic Documents Before the Courts

The central provision lies in the Electronic Transactions Law concerning the application of rules of evidence. An electronic document shall not be denied admissibility merely because it was presented in non-original form, provided it represents the best evidence reasonably expected under the circumstances. Its evidential weight shall be assessed in light of specific evaluative criteria, including:

1. The reliability of the method by which the data was entered, created, stored, transmitted, or presented. 2. The reliability of the manner in which data integrity was maintained. 3. The reliability of the data source, where identifiable. 4. The reliability of the method used to verify the identity of the originator, where relevant.

This provision constitutes the legal essence of the WhatsApp evidence issue: such messages are not rejected merely because they are electronic; rather, they are weighed against standards of integrity, reliability, and proper attribution.

Fourth: The Relationship with the Law of Evidence – Why Does the OMR 1,000 Threshold Matter?

The Law of Evidence in Civil and Commercial Matters (Royal Decree No. 68/2008) establishes an important practical rule: in non-commercial matters, if the legal act exceeds OMR 1,000 in value, or is of unspecified value, witness testimony alone is inadmissible to prove its existence or extinction, subject to certain exceptions.

In the context of WhatsApp communications, many civil disputes exceed this monetary threshold, thereby rendering **written evidence** central to proof. Here lies the importance of the Electronic Transactions Law, which recognizes that an electronic document constitutes written evidence and produces legal effects, thus supporting reliance upon electronic correspondence as valid written proof when it meets reliability requirements.

Fifth: Judicial Direction from the Supreme Court – Electronic Message as Evidence

It is noteworthy that the Supreme Court of Oman, in a published commercial principle (Principle No. 235 – SC 17–18, Appeals No. 1323/2019, session dated 20/10/2020), held that an electronic message produces its legal effect and may be relied upon where it is not denied by the opposing party.

Although this principle referred to the previous legislation (prior to the repeal of Royal Decree No. 69/2008 by Royal Decree No. 39/2025), it remains a strong indicator of the judiciary’s approach toward electronic communications: courts may rely upon them where satisfied as to their authenticity and integrity.

Sixth: When Do WhatsApp Messages Gain Strength as Evidence?

Such messages generally gain evidential strength where the following elements are present:

1. Clarity of content: a specific agreement, acknowledgment of debt, confirmation of receipt, defined price, date, or condition. 2. Completeness of context: submission of the full conversation or the relevant portion without distortion or selective extraction. 3. Attribution of the account: the phone number is recognized in prior dealings, saved by both parties, referenced in contracts, invoices, or prior correspondence, or expressly acknowledged. 4. Technical integrity: preservation in a manner preventing tampering and enabling verification of non-alteration. 5. Corroborative evidence: bank transfers, invoices, delivery notes, witness testimony, official correspondence—forming a coherent evidentiary chain.

Seventh: What Weakens Electronic Messages? Common Mistakes Leading to Case Loss

1. Sole reliance on screenshots in substantial disputes involving denial. 2. Absence of linkage between the phone number and its alleged owner (particularly if registered under another person or entity). 3. Signs of fragmentation, omission, or inconsistent timestamps. 4. Failure to preserve evidence at the onset of dispute (deleting messages, changing devices, losing the original data).

Legal Recommendations for Companies and Individuals

1. Where an agreement is significant, subsequently formalize it in a short written contract or official email reiterating agreed terms. 2. Upon emergence of a dispute, refrain from alteration or deletion; maintain backup copies and preserve the device containing the messages. 3. In high-value disputes, early legal action to secure and present the evidence in a technically reliable manner is advisable, as data integrity and reliability of presentation are decisive in the court’s evidential assessment.

Conclusion

WhatsApp conversations are neither automatically conclusive proof nor categorically inadmissible. They constitute electronic evidence that may be decisive or weak depending on how they are collected, preserved, attributed, and corroborated. Given that each dispute has its own particularities, evaluating electronic communications prior to initiating or responding to litigation may save time and cost—and may ultimately determine the outcome of the case.

Written by: Mohammed Al Battashi, Advocate